Gesualdo Six (Concert Review)
Gesualdo Six – Make That Five
Gesualdo Six
Miller Theatre Early Music Series
Church of St. Mary the Virgin
November 12, 2026
NEW YORK – On Thursday night at Church of St. Mary the Virgin, the vocal ensemble Gesualdo Six appeared in concert without one of their members, countertenor Guy James, who was ill. Singing bespoke repertoire for six voices, one to a part, makes a single singer’s absence a logistical nightmare. Undeterred, the group performed a modified program, mostly of quintets with a couple of quartets. If you didn’t know in advance of the last minute substitutions of repertoire, you would have thought that this was simply a well-rehearsed and tour-tested evening of music going perfectly according to plan.
The group sang a piece by their namesake, giving a vividly emotive rendering of Gesualdo’s chromatic and declamatory writing in Languisce al fin. Tudor era composers John Sheppard and Thomas Tallis were featured. The latter’s Absterge Domine put the ensemble’s lower voices, baritone Simon Grant and bass Owain Park, on display in impressively resounding fashion. Even shy a countertenor, Gesualdo Six displayed a rich sound in the upper register too, particularly in the evergreen O Silver Swan by Orlando Gibbons.
While they are well known for singing early works, Gesualdo Six are also strong advocates for contemporary music. Selections from the group’s 2026 recording The Wishing Tree featured on the concert. Alison Willis’s The Wind’s Warning blends blustery whooshing sounds with closely voiced harmonies in a setting of a poem by Ivor Gurney. Put Out Into the Deep, by David Bednall, uses declamatory solos haloed by shimmering added note chords to vividly depict the story of Jesus calling Peter to be his disciple. An arrangement by James Whitbourn of a traditional song, The Lark in the Clear Air, supplied abundant lyricism. Park’s melodious Phos Hilaron was a standout, its fetching countertenor line delivered with considerable delicacy. A piece from their Christmas album, O Little Rose, O Dark Rose, by Gerda Blok-Wilson, moved between octave and unison passages to affecting harmonies, building to a soaring climax followed by a delicate conclusion.
The show must go on, even in the choral realm. One hopes the rest of their tour is illness free, and looks forward to their return to St. Mary’s next Fall.
-Christian Carey

