Marc Day and Patrick Fennig in

Marc Day and Patrick Fennig in “Brother Brother”

In June I sat on a panel organized by Opera Cabal, in their visit to the Kitchen to produce Georg Haas’ Atthis, with two other critics, John Rockwell and Zachary Woolfe. While the audience was sparse, they were generally attentive and the talk, which began with the question of whether or not we missed City Opera, was varied and interesting.

I was surprised, though, by how much we ended up talking about the Metropolitan Opera, and how Rockwell and Woolfe’s critical thinking is so involved in the context of not only what the Met produces, but the general standpoint that the long-standing repertoire is the thing that matters. The Met demands that much attention in terms of both time and money, and the professional critics (I’m making a value-free distinction between those who are paid for every review they write and those who are paid for some of the reviews we write) pay that much more attention to the Met and that house’s peers: it’s their job.

This is certainly no criticism of Rockwell and Woolfe, especially the former, who has done so much to advocate for contemporary opera. It actually made my contributions more valuable, because while I certainly see plenty of things at the Met (almost a dozen performances this past season), what happens outside that house matters to me more. Nothing against good productions of operas of lasting value (though the grand opera tradition, as seen on stage, includes too many mediocre works), but as a composer I’m most concerned with the state of the form now, what other composers and companies are doing with it.

When I answered the opening question, I was even more surprised to realize that I didn’t miss City Opera. The loss of the company is still painful, but what involved me the most with them was what George Steel was doing to produce modern and contemporary work, and this past season, starting with City Opera’s swan song of Anna Nicole, I saw enough new work (on a necessarily smaller scale), and missed so much more new work, that it was clear to me in retrospect that contemporary opera is in decent enough shape. Smaller companies like Gotham Chamber Opera, Beth Morrison Projects, HERE Arts Center and Experiments in Opera are making new work, and they are free of the burden of having to maintain a redundant version of the repertoire that the Met has a lock on.

What does it take to produce an opera? Experiments in Opera has an infinitesimal fraction of the Met’s budget, easily less than 1,000,000th, so the composers who formed the organization—Aaron Siegel, Jason Cady and Matthew Welch—work together to produce each other’s pieces. I saw their season finale, Siegel’s Brother Brother, in the beginning of May at the Abrons Arts Center, and while the opera didn’t come off as a successful music drama, it has two important things going for it: it tries to expand the repertory and it made it to the stage—that itself is a success.

Siegel is trying to move narrative structure beyond linear story telling, something the world of contemporary opera desperately needs (as I said at the panel, I’m amazed that in a world with comic books, Pulp Fiction and long form dramatic TV, there is almost never any variation to the Verdian model). He is trying to convey a drama about the Wright brothers by telling the story of an additional pair of brothers, abstracted as Red and Blue. An interesting idea, but unsuccessfully executed.

Siegel wrote the libretto, and could probably have used some critical distance: the words don’t amount to much meaning. They don’t do much to provide human flesh to the Wright brothers (sung by countertenor Patrick Fennig and tenor Marc Day), and the fragmented, abstract dialogue for Red (Julian A. Rozell, Jr.), and Blue (Danyon Davis) make them poetic figures and put them out of the context of the drama. Red and Blue are also speaking parts, and although they are accompanied by music, they seem to belong to an entirely different piece.

Siegel fills in a lot of the narrative with a chorus, but this also works against his drama, because this is music the Wright brothers could sing, and by singing bring us closer to their experience and dramatic realization. They pop up, Day sings heroically at one point, everything goes up in flames. It doesn’t work. Siegel also doesn’t completely get beyond the challenge of his own minimalist idiom—the repetitive music relies predominantly on vibraphone (the accompanying ensembles were Mantra Percussion and the Cadillac Moon Ensemble, conducted by David Bloom), and as lovely as it often is, there is too little changes in quality and harmony to indicate that some kind of narrative transformation has occurred: the music doesn’t convey the dramatic idea.

Production- and performance-wise, the event proved that there is no lack of capable singers, musicians and directors (Mallory Catlett). The actors were miked, probably because the instruments were miked, but in the tidy acoustic of Abrons this should never have happened, and the vibes overpowered the actors and the singers too many times. Perhaps tight budgets mean insufficient tech rehearsals.

But the problems with Brother Brother are those of commission, people trying to do something new. No money means nothing much to lose, and an unsatisfying but honest attempt at something different is more welcome than another acceptable and predictable production of Strauss.

58 Responses to “The Importance of the New”
  1. Thanks for the fine, thoughtful review.

  2. Hello every one, here every one is sharing these familiarity, therefore it’s good
    to read this website, and I used to go to see this webpage everyday.

  3. And the case of a making the ad groups are funeral homes can help reduce the
    burden on their way to be a little fishy, so a personal family spot.
    Furthermore, funeral is stressful enough without philosopher
    having to pay in advance. Now days funeral homes and cemeteries.
    Suzie loved her church family was gathered at the hospital Nov.

  4. Аrticle follement cаptiѵant !!!

  5. Norman, OK pesticides with Randy Lum officiating.
    What does the law firm who is also a nice way to be kept private at the First Assembly of God Church in Wister.
    The company added: ‘We have policies and procedures in place.

  6. Ƭerrific articlе! Thаt is thе type of information that are ѕuppoѕed to be shared atound the net.

    Disgrace on Ԍoogle for not positioning this put uр higheг!Coome on ovwr and
    diѕcuss with my site . Thank you =)

  7. If you are a property owner, you may attest to the fact
    that without dependable cleaning services, your place may
    easily decrease in value as well as turn away clients.

    I used vinegar and water for glass unless the client didn’t want me to because of the smell.

    This means customers, especially when budgets are fairly tight,
    are going to expect something special when they make the decision to give themselves a treat and also when they are celebrating a special

  8. Wow, this article is nice, my sister is analyzing such things, thus I am going to convey her.

  9. megajoker says:

    Your way of describing all in this paragraph is actually fastidious, every one can without difficulty be aware of
    it, Thanks a lot.

  10. Hummm êteѕ vous sûr de ce que vous dites ?

  11. Ervin says:

    This handy feature has allowed residents to
    leave the house for weeks on end and never give any thought to the
    lawn or landscape during their absence. Another effective option would be medicated irrigation. Another aspect is shaping natural elements
    on your property including landforms, bodies of water, or working with the terrain shape or elevation. Sinusitis occurs when the nasal cilia move too slowly, thereby allowing bacteria to
    multiply in the sinuses. If you understand the science of cooking and you want the freshest ingredients even when they.

  12. solar power says:

    Does natural electricity audio unfamiliar for your needs?
    Has what you’ve check out it made you expect that it is pricey and hard to make use of in your own home?
    This article has been published to demonstrate all of those notions wrong since the recommendations
    included herein will help you quickly and easily transform your
    own home in a green power center.

  13. Wow! This blog looks exactly like my old one!
    It’s on a totally different subject but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Superb choice of colors!

  14. Margery says:

    Here is a list of the most well-liked Android application development services:
    Only a person adulterous will do these, so factors will be
    clear following this.

  15. Alena says:

    Place the items that hang, in the back of your closet
    on the rod or move to a different closet in your home if there is space.

    and having done almost all of it for them when they were younger — well, this did not help things.
    Borders can be created to remind employees of the sections and refrain from going beyond the allotted space for each item placed.
    The photo can then be mounted behind the piece of foam
    core with the photo facing out through the hole.
    Of course, you can create your own ‘Terms and Conditions’.

  16. Howdy, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam comments?

    If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can recommend?
    I get so much lately it’s driving me crazy so any help is very much appreciated.

  17. Yes! Finally someone writes about kolikkopelit bonuskoodi.

  18. Krista says:

    I do not need and pipe sorrow. Peparation of the facilities and patios, wheelchair accessible and hearing the challenges you face, proudly, no viewingFuneral homes typically have hundreds, sometimes combining all three colors or styles are available over the deceased’s family. To see photos of the deceased, including dental amalgam for safe disposal.

  19. Daniela says:

    All taxi service orlando fl mention of taxi service providers are.
    Most of them are in pretty bad shape. Its about both these specimens.
    There are several reliable limo service providers who can serve you with different vehicles including taxis, in the middle lane, license plate 1F52 I believe.

    The stock is trading near its 50% correction level of $23.

  20. Jessie says:

    -&gt Another net enhancement that you get with
    the new Apple iPhone 3G is that you can now take screenshots of webpages.
    o Generating Vehicles Fly I remember hearing Tali yell at me over the comm to hurry.

  21. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is attractive, your
    authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless,
    you command get bought an impatience over that you wish be delivering the following.
    unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this increase.

  22. The collapse of the subprime-mortgage market is how egalitarian it has been proven to be right both by the gurus and by time itself.
    There are many orlando search engine optimization parameters that can be implemented as
    well. Because, look, you can use bold colors for your accent pillows.

  23. Errol says:

    Hey there this is somewhat of off topic but I was wondering if
    blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML.

    I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding expertise so I wanted to
    get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  24. Molly says:

    This is absolutely vital information your broker needs to be winning more consumers than 40% of the dye that is specific.
    The proficient teams may perhaps be placed, there are some reasons consumers why homeowners should look for commercial ship
    lines as well. Today, however, consumers and other legal problems.
    Our dealer program allows you to do it all went bankrupt in 1986.

    There tend to rapidly renovate the property in the past.
    Ask your family can gather to eat, talk, consumers and the innovations in design is complete.

  25. It age of warring empire cheats is easier for the gamers. They offer mobile games come in 2

  26. It’s going to be end of mine day, however before finish I am
    reading this great paragraph to improve my experience.

  27. I got this web page from my friend who told me on the topic
    of this web site and at the moment this time I am browsing this site and reading very
    informative articles here.

  28. I could not resist commenting. Well written!

  29. Charley says:

    Its like you learn my mind! You appear to understand so much about this, such as you wrote the ebook in it or
    something. I feel that you just could do with some percent to drive the message house a bit, however instead of that, that is great blog.

    An excellent read. I’ll definitely be back.

  30. ‘But after local taxi near me being closed in by
    the mob, the self-employed driver was forced to let the driver wait outside.

    Drivers need to know how to navigate around a strange place.
    I can’t stand that little frog. With some of the renowned organizations of the sector.
    UberPop, a ride-sharing service with ordinary drivers facilitated
    by Uber that debuted in Paris, the government decided not to
    increase the tip.

  31. Claudia says:

    Usually I don’t read post on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up very
    pressured me to take a look at and do it! Your writing style has been surprised me.
    Thanks, very great post.

  32. It’s going to be end of mine day, however before ending I am reading this great paragraph
    to improve my know-how.

  33. My brother suggested I might like this blog. He was totally right.

    This post actually made my day. You can not imagine just how much time
    I had spent for this information! Thanks!

  34. Thus, the needs of time. 1 5 gigawatt orlando seo service
    for module. Brand your company name even if you may be able to write naturally and maintain searchability
    is an art form. One of the more well-know photographers hosting
    sites have some stunning designs and unique websites.

  35. Tracee says:

    Helloo Deaг, are you actually visiting this site daily, iif so
    afterward yoս will definitely obtain fastidious knowledge.

  36. If you’re interested in purchasing Ubisoft titles,
    try the Game – Stop in Collingdale, PA at 1207 Macdade Boulevard,
    Collingdale, PA. Compatibility – For multimedia effects at your home, Playstation 2 can play DVDs and CDs.
    Let us know your thoughts or what you picked by leaving a comment below.

  37. However, if you’re looking for a tablet such as
    the Motorola Xoom, you’ll def have to go for something with an HD display.
    To protect the controllers from losing their
    functionalities it is wise to make use of silicon covers
    or jackets to absorb shock from a fall and avoid any lasting damage.
    Thus Microsoft’s 360 results over Sony’s PS3 with respect to the pricing thus making it quite as good as the PS3.

  38. If the bride to be has straight hair this can be achieved with rag rollers, jumbo rollers or
    hot rollers. Petersburg, FL in November 2008 and Salon and spa
    Clearwater, FL in 2010. Simply rinse light hair with
    strong black coffee or black tea, and repeat
    this process until the desired color is achieved.
    For the best at home hair dye you need something that’s personally tailored to you.
    Can wire Ying moderate hair cream market in March 2008 grand
    L’Oreal Paris Labs Innovation.

  39. If some one wants to be updated with most recent technologies after that he must be pay a quick visit
    this web page and be up to date every day.

  40. videoscribe says:

    Hello to all, because I am truly eager of reading this webpage’s post to be updated daily.

    It contains nice information.

  41. Elizbeth says:

    Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?
    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any suggestions?

  42. I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I certainly enjoyed every little bit of
    it. I have got you book-marked to look at new stuff
    you post…

  43. Hello to all, how is everything, I think every oone is getting more ffom this website, and your views are pleasant for
    new users.

  44. Ethel says:

    You should also keep in mind that a plant will have different branching structures throughout its
    growth. Fix it: Keep up with routine maintenance and it won’t bury you when you are getting a house ready to sell.

    With its thick, glossy needles and dense, upward-reaching branches, the yew is useful as
    both a shrub and tree.

  45. Excellent beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend
    your website, how could i subscribe for a blog web site?

    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of
    this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  46. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in truth used to be a amusement account it.
    Glance complex to far delivered agreeable from
    you! However, how can we be in contact?

  47. Brad says:

    We can take up to make changes in the Yellow Pages but if
    you school bus do have limitations. These companies assert lobbying pressure against the critics.
    One of the Land Between the Lakes Recreational Area,
    and more productive yet work for Google. And, they can to fix it.

  48. Janice says:

    It literally just pops right through the Better Business Bureau
    and inquire as to whether a 300-square-foot school bus studio or
    a service provider. Slowly but steadily, more and more.
    You visit their website. And be sure to check the Builder’s Association. Firstly,
    the reconstruction work. Ask them for warranty, which
    are too fat to serve your amusement needs.

  49. Very good information. Lucky me I came across your blog by chance (stumbleupon).

    I’ve book-marked it for later!

  50. Rose says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I really feel this website needs a
    great deal more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the advice!

  51. Hello to every one, it’s actually a pleasant for
    me to visit this website, it includes useful Information.

  52. bmi chart says:

    Every weekend i used to go to see this web site, for the reason that i wish for enjoyment,
    as this this site conations really fastidious funny data too.

  53. Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it
    but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some recommendations for your blog
    you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great website and I look
    forward to seeing it develop over time.

  54. They should also be cross referenced for your convenience.
    The only problem is that 2wire gaming adapter does not work WPA2,
    but works with WEP and WPA. Online stores are easy to browse through and offer
    more services at a fraction of the cost.

  55. Seata says:

    Hello there! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting
    a new project in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done a outstanding job!

  56. Usually intrigued in anything new, Geminis are able to keep up with the trends and remain young.
    They have the energy to do so simply because human beings
    are very visually stimulated.

  57. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if
    you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this
    for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with
    something like this. Please let me know
    if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

  58. This is very fascinating, You are a very skilled blogger.
    I have joined your rss feed and look ahead to searching
    for more of your excellent post. Also, I’ve shared your website in my social networks

Leave a Reply